In recent years, Meghan Markle and her relationship with the British Royal Family have sparked a global conversation, particularly among Americans. Many people in the U.S. have voiced their support for the Duchess of Sussex, often siding with her in disputes involving the monarchy. But what is it about Meghan Markle that resonates with so many Americans, and why do they seem to take her side over that of the British Royal Family?
Here are several key reasons:
One of the primary reasons Americans empathize with Meghan Markle is her background. Born and raised in Los Angeles, California, she represents the modern American woman. Her experience growing up in a multiracial household—her mother is African-American, and her father is white—reflects the diversity that defines much of American society. As a self-made actress who built her career in Hollywood, many Americans relate to her ambition and independence, which are seen as core values in the U.S.
Moreover, Meghan’s experiences of being an outsider, both racially and culturally, resonate with many Americans who see themselves or their communities reflected in her struggles. This has created a sense of shared identity, where Americans feel that she symbolizes breaking barriers and challenging outdated norms.
To many Americans, the British Royal Family represents a historical institution that seems disconnected from modern values, particularly those of equality and meritocracy. The U.S. has a long-standing cultural opposition to monarchy, rooted in its revolutionary history. The idea of an unelected, hereditary elite often clashes with American ideals of democracy and freedom. As a result, when Meghan’s struggles with the Royal Family became public, many Americans viewed her situation through the lens of a more progressive society pushing back against a traditional, hierarchical system.
The monarchy’s perceived inflexibility also plays a role in this sentiment. Americans are often more accustomed to public figures being transparent about their personal lives and struggles, while the British Royal Family traditionally remains private and guarded. This difference in public expectations has fueled American support for Meghan, who has been more vocal about her challenges.
In interviews, particularly the 2021 Oprah Winfrey interview, Meghan spoke candidly about her mental health struggles while living under the scrutiny of the British press and within the constraints of royal life. Mental health awareness has gained significant traction in the U.S., where open discussions about therapy, anxiety, depression, and other challenges are encouraged. Meghan’s willingness to address these issues publicly struck a chord with many Americans who value vulnerability and transparency regarding mental well-being.
Her revelations about feeling isolated and unsupported resonated with many Americans, particularly women and people of color, who could relate to similar experiences of feeling marginalized or unsupported in their own lives.
Race has been a central theme in the debate surrounding Meghan Markle, both in the U.K. and the U.S. From the moment her relationship with Prince Harry became public, Meghan faced racially charged criticism, particularly from British tabloids. Many Americans, particularly those from minority communities, saw this as an extension of the systemic racism that persists in many societies.
In the U.S., where conversations about race and racial inequality are more prominent, many viewed the treatment of Meghan as an example of how institutions—whether royal or otherwise—can perpetuate racial biases. Americans who are passionate about social justice and anti-racism efforts were more inclined to support Meghan, seeing her as a victim of unfair and racially motivated criticism.
Meghan’s position as an outsider to the royal institution further aligns with the American cultural affinity for “underdog” stories. In the U.S., people often root for individuals who challenge entrenched systems or fight against the odds. Meghan, as a biracial, American divorcee entering the British Royal Family, was seen by many as an outsider who would face considerable challenges. When stories of her struggles with royal protocols and tabloid scrutiny surfaced, it solidified her status as a relatable figure in the eyes of many Americans.
The narrative of Meghan "breaking free" from royal life with Prince Harry by her side only strengthened this image. Many in the U.S. viewed the couple’s decision to step back from royal duties and move to California as a victory for personal freedom and happiness over institutional pressure.
In the U.S., celebrity culture is pervasive, and Meghan Markle was already a recognizable figure before her royal wedding, thanks to her acting career, particularly her role on the TV show Suits. Americans often have a deep connection to their celebrities, seeing them not just as public figures but as relatable individuals with real struggles. This emotional connection, combined with media coverage that often favors Meghan’s perspective, plays a significant role in shaping public opinion.
Additionally, Meghan and Prince Harry’s collaboration with American media outlets and their ventures into philanthropy and entertainment through deals with Netflix and Spotify have kept them in the public eye. This media presence ensures that Meghan’s story remains part of the cultural conversation, with a narrative that often casts her in a sympathetic light.
Americans' support for Meghan Markle in her ongoing tensions with the British Royal Family is rooted in a combination of cultural identification, empathy for her struggles with mental health and racism, and a broader skepticism of monarchy as an institution. As an outsider to the royal system and a familiar face in American media, Meghan represents a break from tradition that many Americans celebrate. In a country that values individuality, diversity, and personal freedom, it's no surprise that so many Americans continue to side with her in this royal saga.
By understanding these cultural and societal factors, it's clear why Meghan Markle has garnered such significant support in the U.S., even as she continues to face criticism from other quarters.
