The original "Come On Eileen" is a fusion of folk instrumentation and high-energy rock, driven by Kevin Rowland’s distinct vocals. Carpenter’s cover, while maintaining the song's spirit, leans more into a polished pop production. She embraces the original melody but gives it a fresh twist with a smoother, more contemporary vocal delivery.
Kevin Rowland's raw, theatrical delivery in the original gave the song an unmistakable character, making it feel almost rebellious and celebratory at the same time. Carpenter’s vocals, however, bring a more polished and controlled sound, which appeals to modern pop listeners but lacks the original's grittiness and spontaneity.
The fiddles and banjos in the Dexys Midnight Runners' version create a unique folk-rock atmosphere that made the song iconic. Carpenter’s version tones down the folk elements in favor of a more synth-driven and radio-friendly production. While this makes the song more accessible to younger audiences, it does lose some of the original’s rustic charm.
Carpenter’s cover has sparked a debate among music fans.
Both versions have their strengths:
Music is subjective, and covers can serve as a bridge between generations. Whether you’re a die-hard fan of the original or appreciate Carpenter’s fresh take, "Come On Eileen" continues to be a song that stands the test of time.
